Fico Resilience Score

FICO® Resilience Score Just Misses the Mark

How does the FICO® Resilience Score Affect consumers?

With two great financial crises hitting the American consumer in a dozen years, FICO’s new consumer resilience index offers prospective lenders a powerful new tool for their evaluation toolbox. Such a score can provide particularly critical information when analyzing consumers with fair credit scores to determine how they might weather future financial crises.

Like other FICO scores, the FICO Resilience Index is clearly meant for lenders, not for consumers. The score ranges from 1-99 rather than a clear 0-100. Additionally, the lower the score the better the consumer’s potential financial resilience rather than the intuitive ranking of assigning higher numbers to better performance.

FICO has responded to increasingly frequent volatility in the economy by formulating and releasing its Resilience Index (FICO-RI). FICO-RI analyzes a consumer’s credit report information, compares it to historical credit information along with the successes and failures of corresponding loans before and after the Great Recession, and produces a two-digit number that fairly accurately predicts a consumer’s likelihood of paying accounts as agreed during a future financial crisis or defaulting on those accounts (i.e. missing payments).

It’s a brilliant move by FICO and a helpful product for lenders, given the increasing volatility of the world economy over the past 25 years.

That said, FICO continues to both ignore the obvious and obscure the essential: consumers care about their credit scores even if they are meant for lenders (obvious), and the scoring model offers no intuitive advice to the consumer (essential). Although the score is for lenders, consumers will eventually hear about it, want to understand it and value its role in their credit. A more intuitive range of scores would make this understanding and the ability to value the score much easier.

The Value of FICO® Scores

The typical American consumer, especially under 50, takes their FICO scores for granted. The collective memory of credit before FICO is already so lost that many assume FICO has been around for a century. It’s hard to believe that it was only 1995 when HUD lenders Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac began recommending FICO scores in the evaluation of mortgage loans.

Before FICO, loan applications – whether for home loans, car loans, and even credit cards – took not seconds, not minutes, and not even days, but weeks and even months to evaluate before approving or rejecting. The three consumer reporting agencies (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) eventually brought digitalization to credit reports, but FICO pioneered the automated statistical analysis of that data.

Because the FICO scoring system was created for lender databases and lending algorithms, its scores typically range from 300 on the low end to 850 on the top end. As a result, the score creates confusion and, worse, speculation among consumers who know their score is critical to the lending process but who find it difficult to understand FICO’s meaning to them personally. For this reason, many consumers have developed a distaste for FICO, believing it unfairly harms low-income consumers, for example, because they believe income is a scoring factor (it is not).

In fact, during the early days of the COVID-19 lockdown, many well-meaning but misguided consumer advocates began calling for FICO to change its scoring to stop hurting those who were out of work and had lost their income. Such a move would have brought all loans to a screeching stop. How could a lender evaluate the risk prospective borrowers present if they had no valid and reliable method for such an analysis?

FICO serves a critical and quite effective role in our lending practices. It does not depend upon income, race, place of residence, religion, gender identity, or any other potentially discriminatory issue. Instead, it considers your past behavior with loans (payment history, balances, account statuses, etc.) and attempts to project that behavior into the future. It may not prove 100% accurate, but it has proven reliable enough to allow lenders to offer more loans to more people at fair rates (low interest for low risk and high interest for high risk).

How the Resilience Index Will Affect Consumers

Like most FICO credit scores, FICO-RI depends entirely on information found on consumer reports. It does not use information such as income, employment status, marital status, or other non-credit-related data. FICO-RI does not aim to replace other credit scores but complements them. Used in tandem with other FICO scores, FICO-RI provides greater confidence to the lender in predicting their future risk in making loans to consumers.

For the 45% or so of US consumers who Experian already classifies as having very good or exceptional credit, the FICO-RI will likely have little to no effect. They should find it no more difficult and no easier to qualify for a loan now that FICO has released its Resiliency Index. Their FICO-RI score will probably calculate somewhere between 1 and 44 or even 59.

Likewise, the 15% or so of American consumers rated as having very poor credit will still find it just as difficult to secure a loan as before. Their FICO-RI will likely end up in the 70-99 range.

For the nearly 40% of consumers rated with Fair or Good credit scores, FICO-RI may make it easier or harder to qualify for a loan. This segment of the population, with FICO scores roughly between 580 and 670, requires a more nuanced scoring system than the standard FICO in order to predict who will fair during an economic downturn. Many will get through relatively unscathed while others will lose employment, lose income, and begin to miss payments, possibly even heading for bankruptcy. FICO-RI will classify such consumers as “Sensitive” to economic crises, placing them somewhere between 60 and 69.

How the FICO® Resilience Index Differs from Other Scores

All credit scores attempt to predict a consumer’s future credit-related behavior based on their past credit-related behavior. If the consumer has been paying his or her recent debts on time and as agreed, credit scoring systems assume they will continue to do so, earning them a higher credit score.

What credit scoring models have lacked is the economic volatility factor. If the consumer has only had credit for five years, all five of which have been part of prosperous economic growth, traditional credit scores, including FICO scores, do not predict how that consumer will behave in relation to their debts during a recession or a worldwide economic lockdown.

FICO used data from thousands of anonymous consumer reports from before and after the Great Recession of the late 2000s and early 2010s to clarify what sort of credit histories and backgrounds make consumers more and less likely to weather financial crises well.

What FICO® Got Right

As has been proven over several decades of successful use, the FICO score accurately predicts future credit-related behavior. While time will tell how many prospective lenders adopt FICO-RI as an extra tool in their processes, you can bet FICO tested and retested their technology. Will FICO-RI get it right every time? Not hardly, but neither does FICO Ultra or FICO 8, 9, or 10 (or any FICO model, for that matter). That should not detract from its usefulness.

The Missed Opportunities

As the FICO Resilience Index catches on, consumers will likely begin hearing about it from their lenders. When talking to family members and friends about getting a loan, many will mention the “new” FICO score the lender shared with them, not realizing it serves as a companion to and not a replacement of their FICO score. When asked about their FICO-RI score, the consumer will struggle to remember the simple fact that the new FICO-RI range is upside down and unintelligible for most consumers. As a result, consumer confusion will lead to a false understanding of FICO-RI and potentially to mistrust, as we have seen with the standard FICO score from vulnerable populations.

Since FICO introduced FICO-RI as a brand new product, it had the opportunity to create a rating system that made sense to both lenders and consumers alike, such as one like the school grading systems (90%-100% is exceptional, 80%-89% is good, and so forth). Yes, we understand the lower the score, the lower the risk to the lender. In reality, though, lenders employ consumers who would have no trouble adjusting to the idea that a higher score means the consumer fits better with the lender.

The only obvious justification for the odd scoring range involves lender databases and how the FICO-RI might fit in. Because it is a new score, though, and lenders will need to create a new FICO-RI field in their databases and application calculations, it should not have mattered what the score range looked like to a database.

We appreciate you, FICO, for the valid and reliable work you do, but come on! Give us something functional and reasonable when it comes to our scores.

Related Questions

What’s the difference between the FICO Score and the FICO Resilience Index?

FICO scores predict a borrower’s likelihood of paying as agreed in the future based solely on the consumer’s credit report data. FICO incorporated into its Resilience Index larger economic factors to predict how a consumer might behave during future financial crises.

What is the FICO stress-test indicator?

FICO’s Resilience Index offers financial institutions a tool to better address stress-test requirements placed on them by federal law and regulation, including how much capital the lenders are required to keep versus how much they lend.

About the Author

This Website Is Using Cookies. We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our cookie use.

Client Credit Report Authorization

You hereby authorize and instruct Debt Reduction Services, Inc. (DRS, dba Money Fit by DRS) and/or its assigned agents to:
  • Obtain and review your credit report, and
  • Request verifications of your income and rental history, and any other information deemed necessary for improving your housing situation (for example, verifying your annual property tax obligations and homeowner’s insurance fees)
Your credit report will be obtained from a credit reporting agency chosen by DRS. You understand and agree that DRS intends to use the credit report evaluate your financial readiness to purchase or rent a home and/or to engage in post-purchase counseling activities and not to grant credit. You understand you may ask any questions pertaining to your credit report. However, while DRS will review the information with you, the company is not able to furnish you with a copy of your credit profile. You hereby authorize DRS to share your information from your credit report and any information that you provided (including any computations and assessments produced) with the entities listed below to help DRS determine your viable financial options.
  • Banks
  • Counseling Agencies
  • Debt Collectors
  • Landlords
  • Lenders
  • Mortgage Servicers
  • Property Management Companies
  • Public Housing Authorities
  • Social Service Agencies
Entities such as mortgage lenders and/or counseling agencies may contact your DRS counselor to evaluate the options for which you may be eligible. In connection with such evaluation, you authorize the credit reporting and/or financial agencies to release information and cooperate with your DRS counselor. No information will be discussed about you with entities not directly involved in your efforts to improve your housing situation. You hereby authorize the release of your information to program monitoring organizations of DRS, including but not limited to, Federal, State, and nonprofit partners for program review, monitoring, auditing, research, and/or oversight purposes. In addition, you authorize DRS to have your credit report pulled two additional times to conduct program evaluations. You also agree to keep DRS informed of any changes in address, telephone number, job status, marital status, or other conditions which may affect your eligibility for a program you have applied for or a counseling service that you are seeking. Finally, you understand that you may revoke consent to these disclosures by notifying DRS in writing.

Client Privacy, Data Security, and Client Rights Policy

NOTE: This sheet is to inform new or returning clients about our services, records, fees, and limitations that may affect you as a consumer of our services. This form also discloses how we might release your information to other agencies and/or regulators. If you do not understand a statement, please ask a Debt Reduction Services (DRS) counselor for assistance.

Debt Reduction Services, Inc. (DRS) has put into place policies and procedures to protect the security and confidentiality of your nonpublic personal information. This notice explains our online information practices and how we use and maintain your information to conduct our financial education and credit counseling sessions and to fulfill information and question requests. This privacy policy complies with federal laws and regulations.

To provide our financial education and credit counseling services, we collect nonpublic personal information about you as follows: 1) Information we receive from you, 2) Information about your transactions with us or others, and 3) Information we receive from your creditors or a consumer reporting agency. We do not share this information with outside parties.

We use non-identifying and aggregate information to better design our website and services, but we do not disclose anything that could be used to identify you as an individual.

You hereby authorize DRS, when necessary, to share your nonpublic personal, financial, credit, and any information that you provided (including any computations and assessments produced) with the following entities in order to help DRS provide you with appropriate counseling or guide you to appropriate services: third parties such as government agencies, your lender(s), your creditor(s), and nonprofit housing-related and other financial agencies as permitted by law, including the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

To prevent unauthorized access, maintain data accuracy, and ensure the correct use of information, we have put in place appropriate physical, electronic, and managerial procedures to safeguard and secure the information we collect online. We limit access to your nonpublic personal information to our employees, contractors and agents who need such access to provide products or services to you or for other legitimate business purposes.

Debt Reduction Services, Inc. complies with the privacy requirements set forth in the HUD housing counseling agency handbook 7610.1 (05/2010), including the sections 2-2 Mc, 3-1 H(2), 3-3, 5-3 F, and Attachment A.5. At all times, we will comply with all additional laws and regulations to which we are subject regarding the collection, use, and disclosure of individually identifiable information.

  1. Services: DRS provides the following housing-related services: counseling that includes Homeless Assistance, Rental Topics, Pre-purchase/Homebuying, and Home Maintenance and Financial Management for Homeowners (Non-Delinquency Post-Purchase); Education courses that include Financial literacy (including home affordability, budgeting, and understanding use of credit), Predatory lending, loan scam or other fraud prevention, Fair housing, Rental topics, Pre-purchase homebuyer education, Non-delinquency post-purchase workshop (including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners), and other workshops not listed above.

Please refer to DebtReductionServices.org for details of our services.

  1. Limits: Our services are limited to our normal weekday business hours. We do not provide individual counseling or education services after hours or on weekends, although our education courses are available 24/7.
  2. Fees: We do not charge fees for our financial management counseling and education. However, if you use them, you may have to pay for our Debt Management Program, Student Loan Counseling, Bankruptcy Certificate Services or certain financial education courses (homebuyer education, rental topics, fair housing, predatory lending, and post-purchase-non-delinquency including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners).
  3. Records: We maintain records of the services you receive, including notes about your progress or other relevant information to your work with us. You have the right to access and view your records by making a request to your counselor.
  4. Confidentiality: We respect your privacy and offer our services in confidence with the understanding that we may share such information with auditors and government regulators. Certain laws or situations may also lead to disclosing confidential issues, such as those involving potential child abuse or neglect, threats to harm self or others, or court subpoenas.
  5. Refusal of Services: You have the right to refuse services without any penalty or loss.
  6. Disclosure of Policies and Practices: You will be provided our agency disclosure statement.
  7. Sharing of Information: Sometimes we will need to contact other agencies or we may need to share your information, including your records, with other agencies or with regulators. We will do this only if you sign this form that gives us permission except for limited reasons; please see # 5 above for examples of such situations.
  8. Other: You have the right to be treated with respect by our staff, and we expect the same from you in return. We encourage you to always ask questions if something is not clear. We also encouraged you to express your thoughts and advocate throughout our services.

You acknowledge that this authorization will remain in effect for the duration of time that DRS serves as your housing counselor or financial education provider. You also acknowledge that should you wish to terminate this authorization, you will notify DRS in writing.

Disclosure  Statement

NOTE: If you have an impairment, disability, language barrier, or otherwise require an alternative means of completing this form or accessing information about our counseling services, please communicate with your DRS representative about arranging alternative accommodations.

Program Disclosure Form

Disclosure to Client for HUD Housing Counseling Services

Debt Reduction Services, Inc. and its financial education arm, Money Fit by DRS, offer the following housing counseling and educational services related to housing, personal finance, and bankruptcy certificates to consumers:
  • Housing Education Courses: DRS offers many online self-guided education programs classified as Financial, Budgeting, and Credit Workshops (FBC), Fair Housing Pre-Purchase Education Workshops (FHW), Homelessness Prevention Workshops (HMW), Non-Delinquency Post Purchase Workshops (NDW), Predatory Lending Education Workshops (PLW), Pre-purchase Homebuyer Education Workshops (PPW), and Rental Housing Workshops (RHW). These courses help participants increase their knowledge of and skills in personal finance, including home affordability, budgeting, and understanding the use of credit, as well as predatory lending, loan scams, and other fraud prevention topics, fair housing, rental topics, pre-purchase homebuyer education, non-delinquency post-purchase topics including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners, homeless prevention workshop, and other workshops not listed above relating to personal finance and housing. Course details are found below under “Housing Workshops.”
  • Home Equity Conversation Mortgage (HECM) Counseling (RMC): Via telephone and virtual platforms, we offer the required HECM counseling nationwide in addition to in-person counseling in Boise, Idaho. We also offer in-home counseling options in thirty counties across southern Idaho for an additional fee to cover our travel and additional staff time costs.
  • Home Maintenance and Financial Management for Homeowners (Non-Delinquency Post-Purchase) (FBC): Clients receive counseling and materials on the proper maintenance of their home and mortgage refinancing. Clients can find help and resources by phone, in our Boise office, or virtually on all topics related to stabilizing their long-term homeownership.
  • Services for Homeless Counseling (HMC): Clients receive phone, virtual, or in-person (Boise) counseling to evaluate their current housing needs, identify barriers to and goals for housing stability, establish a path to self-sufficiency, and connect with emergency shelters, income-appropriate housing, and/or other community resources (e.g. mental healthcare, job training, transportation, etc.).
  • Pre-Purchase Counseling (PPC): Clients receive counseling through the entire homebuying process. Assistance may involve creating a sustainable household budget, understanding mortgage options, building their credit rating, and putting together a realistic action plan to set and achieve homeownership goals.  Additionally, clients will receive materials and resources about home inspections and other homeownership topics relevant to successfully maintaining a home.
  • Rental Housing Counseling (RHC): Via phone, in-person appointments (Boise, ID), or virtual platforms, clients receive housing counseling relevant to renting, including rent subsidies from HUD or other government and assistance programs. Topics can also address issues and concerns having to do with fair housing, landlord and tenant laws, lease terms, rent delinquency, household budgeting, and finding alternate housing.
DRS also offers the following services:
  • A Debt Management Program (DMP) for consumers struggling to pay their credit cards, collections, medical debts, personal loans, old utility bills, and past-due cell phone accounts;
  • The Budget Briefing and Debtor Education Certificates that are required during the Bankruptcy filing process;
  • A Student Loan Repayment Plan Counseling and application service.

Relationships with Industry Partners

Through such services, DRS has established financial relationships with hundreds of banks, credit unions, and creditors such as American Express, Bank of America, Barclays, Capital One, Chase, Citibank, Credit One, Discover, Synchrony, US Bank, USAA, Wells Fargo, and others.

No Client Obligation

The client is not obligated to receive, purchase or utilize any other services offered by DRS or its exclusive partners to receive financial education or housing counseling services. Alternatives: As a condition of our counseling services, in alignment with meeting our client services goals, and in compliance with HUD’s Housing Counseling Program requirements, we may provide information on alternative services, programs, and products available to you, if applicable and known by our staff. Alternative DMP services include negotiating better repayment terms directly with your individual creditors, paying your debts as agreed, or, in extreme cases, filing for personal bankruptcy. Alternative credit and education services can be found through MyMoney.gov or the Jump$tart Clearinghouse of online financial education resources. Housing counseling alternatives can be found through HUD at www.hud.gov/findacounselor.
Finally, you understand that you may revoke consent to these disclosures by notifying DRS in writing.

Housing Counseling and Education Fee Schedule

 

Online Education Program Fees*

Homebuyer Education Course: $59 per participant

  • Self-paced course available here, our online housing counseling and education center. Certificates will be automatically generated upon completion of the course (approximately 6-8 hours)

RentalFair HousingPredatory Lending / HOEPAPost-Purchase (Non-delinquency post-purchase workshop, including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners) Online Workshops: $49 per participant

  • Approximately 1 hour each

Other Self-Guided Financial Literacy Webinars (e.g. creditbudgetinghomeless preventiondebt prevention): $0

One-on-one Counseling Fees*

Pre-purchase Homebuying Counseling, Rental Counseling, Post-purchase Ownership Maintenance and Financial Management: $75

  • Session by the hour

Reverse Mortgage/HECM Counseling with Required Certificate:

  • $200†

Credit Report Fee: Paid Directly by Client

*Fees for all but our online education courses and workshops can be paid online by debit card, credit card, or PayPal or in person by cash, check or money order to: “Debt Reduction Services, Inc.” Registration fees are non-refundable 24 hours or less before the start of an in-person course or workshop. Certificates are non-transferable

*Fees may be waived for households with income of 150% or less of that identified on the US Department of Health and Human Services Poverty Guidelines Page

†Home visit counseling is available in 30 southern Idaho counties for potential HECM borrowers at additional costs to cover our travel (IRS reimbursement rates apply) and staff time ($50 per hour or fraction there).

Housing Counseling and Education Fee Schedule

 

Online Education Program Fees*

Homebuyer Education Course: $59 per participant

  • Self-paced course available here, our online housing counseling and education center. Certificates will be automatically generated upon completion of the course (approximately 6-8 hours)

RentalFair HousingPredatory Lending / HOEPAPost-Purchase (Non-delinquency post-purchase workshop, including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners) Online Workshops: $49 per participant

  • Approximately 1 hour each

Other Self-Guided Financial Literacy Webinars (e.g. creditbudgetinghomeless preventiondebt prevention): $0

One-on-one Counseling Fees*

Pre-purchase Homebuying Counseling, Rental Counseling, Post-purchase Ownership Maintenance and Financial Management: $75

  • Session by the hour

Reverse Mortgage/HECM Counseling with Required Certificate:

  • $200†

Credit Report Fee: Paid Directly by Client

*Fees for all but our online education courses and workshops can be paid online by debit card, credit card, or PayPal or in person by cash, check or money order to: “Debt Reduction Services, Inc.” Registration fees are non-refundable 24 hours or less before the start of an in-person course or workshop. Certificates are non-transferable

*Fees may be waived for households with income of 150% or less of that identified on the US Department of Health and Human Services Poverty Guidelines Page

†Home visit counseling is available in 30 southern Idaho counties for potential HECM borrowers at additional costs to cover our travel (IRS reimbursement rates apply) and staff time ($50 per hour or fraction there).